BC Rugby Weekend of October 24th 2026

BC Premier Week 6 Results: Westshore Defeat CW, UBC Edged by UVic, Rowers Paddled by Ravens, Bays Conquer Lomas

The Bays remain the only undefeated team in the league at 4-0. A bittersweet day for UVic, they won the match but lost the university championship qualification to UBC, just coming up short on point differential.

It’s Week 6 of the BC Premier, the men’s national XVs team are apparently leaving on Sunday for their November tour, so some names will be missing. The big game is UVic v UBC to determine who goes to the national university championships. They are currently ranked #3 and #2 nationally but due to the current qualifying system, one of them will miss out while an unranked team from Alberta will qualify, two teams from Quebec, two from Ontario, one from Atlantic and host TWU. U SPORTS combines BC and Alberta as one region in women’s rugby.

Castaway Wanderers 12 v Westshore 56 @ Windsor Park @ 2:30
Ref: Jack Webster AR: Finley Rose, Ryan Burrell

Westshore stay in the race for the top going 4-1 and sitting at 20 points. CW stay at 1-4 and 5 points. Next week Westshore visit UVic and CW visit Capilano.

PREGAME

#10 hosting #5. Westshore with a huge upset over last year’s champions Ravens last week. CW lost to Meraloma.

Westshore missing Jesse Kilgour, Matt Oworu and Kyle Tremblay, also Joe Kingham out this week. The national U20 players are back from Chile, Porter Gook starting at hooker and Chris Rose on the bench. It will be brother v brother when Chris comes on at scrum half with brother Josh as #10 for CW. Seth Recalma returns to the roster in the second row.

CW with a stable roster, #8 John Wallace moves to hooker and Theo Espagnol moves to tighthead prop. Chris Gamage missing this week so Zech Pilgrim starts at #9. George Vorster moves from flanker to #8 and Jaimie Kaefer comes off the bench to start at openside flanker.

Westshore missing a number of key players, they won’t be the same team as last week but should have enough to get the win. Prediction: Westshore by +3.

Westshore (Oct 17th/current)

1 Emerson Prior
2 Matt Evans / Porter Gook
3 Kane Perrett
4 Josh Jukes / William Mwanji
5 Joe Kingham / Seth Recalma
6 Ryder Heaney-Corns / Josh Jukes
7 Taine Clague
8 Matt Oworu / Ryder Heaney-Corns
9 Jesse Kilgour / Natsu Yokoyama
10 Jean-Louis Desgouttes
11 Denis Abukuse
12 Guy Lansdown
13 Kyle Tremblay / Rhys James
14 Natsu Yokoyama / Finn Hussey
15 Rhys James / Oliver May
16 Nathan Groenewold / Matt Evans
17 Liam Ingerson
18 Junoir Atalifo / Nathan Groenewold
19 William Mwanji / Matt Weir
20 Matt Weir / Toby Higgins
21 Grayson Perry / Chris Rose
22 Josh Nordstrom
23 Oliver May / Grayson Perry

CW (Oct 17th/current)

1 John Braddock
2 Theo Espagnol / John Wallace
3 Alexander McCallum / Theo Espagnol
4 Nat Dring
5 Mike Finnemore
6 Hugh Mager
7 George Vorster / Jaimie Kaefer
8 John Wallace / George Vorster
9 Chris Gamage / Zech Pilgrim
10 Josh Rose
11 Shane Rikley-Krindle
12 Liam Poulton
13 Glenn Roy
14 Alex Harper
15 Charlie Duncombe
16 George Brown
17 Fred Regan
18 Tomas Vidal / Alexander McCallum
19 Nate Smith / John Humphries
20 Jamie Kaefer / Charlie Kirkwood
21 Zech Pilgrim / Jacob Isaac
22 Henry Williamson
23 Sam Blundell

UVIC 21 v UBC 15 @ Wallace Field @ 2:30
REF: Chris Assmus AR: Malcolm Klaver, Chris Horsley

UVic won the battle but lost the war. It was a bizarre scene at the end of the match with UVic winning but UBC celebrating. UBC win the head to head by +4 and go to the national university championships plus claim the Coastal Cup. UBC scored first and were up 5-0 through a line break by #13 Alastair Marshall. The Vikes answered back with a maul try, 7-5 for the Vikes. UBC answered back with a maul try of their own, awarded as a penalty try, 12-7 for UBC. Next was UVic with tighthead prop, Brendan Kim, crashing over the line after prolonged pressure inside the UBC 5 metres, 14-12 for UVic. Just before half the national team duo of Cooper Coats and Josh McIndoe teamed up on a tap penalty with McIndoe scoring the try, 21-12 for Vikes at the half. UBC kicked a penalty in the second half to close the gap to 21-15. That was it for the scoring, Vikes were hammering the UBC line at the whistle but knocked it on. The Vikes go to 2-2 and 10 points, UBC get a losing bonus point and sit at 3-2 and 15 points. UBC visit Burnaby next week while the Vikes host Westshore.

PREGAME

#8 hosting #6. The match will count towards the BC Premier standings but the big prize is the national university championship qualification. Only one team goes despite being ranked #2 and #3 nationally. UBC lead the head to head series by +10 so UVic not only need the win, they need the point differential. Also the Coastal Cup will be awarded after the match, that’s the three team series between UBC, UVic and TWU. UBC are 3-0, UVic 2-1, TWU 0-4. A UBC win guarantees them both the uni qualification and the Coastal Cup, a UVic win by more than 10 gives them both, if it’s exactly a +10 UVic win then the tie breaking rules come into effect.

UVic are pulling out all the guns, Cooper Coats is back at #10, Josh McIndoe at #12. Ronin Smith is back at #8, moving Robert Reid to openside flanker. Brendan Kim gets the start at tighthead prop.

UBC are playing their cards close to the vest, the only team without a published roster at the time of writing. Will Cody Nhanala and Stephen Webb suit up is the main question. We’ll update the roster when it’s published. UPDATE: UBC roster in, they’re coming with all their top players, including the returning U20s. Looking up and down the roster now, wondering if the Vikes can pull off the upset. Should be a good one.

This should be a great match and it should be live streamed on the UVic YouTube channel. I’m going to say UVic win at home with Cooper Coats but they don’t get the 10+ margin. Prediction: Vikes by +7.

UBC (Oct 17th/current)

1 Graeme Francolini / Jacob Blackwood
2 Ethan McCarthy
3 Charlie Clark
4 Alex Muir
5 Joe McNulty
6 Callum Arnesen
7 Max Birtley / Cody Nhanala
8 Cody Nhanala / Liam Kinghorn
9 Stephen Webb
10 Caleb Seumanutafa / James Biss
11 Zach Zapanta / Liam James
12 Liam James / Liam Turnbull
13 Alastair Marshall
14 Elijah Palov
15 Max McGavern
16 Emmett Allan
17 Kevin Griffiths / Ethan Samuels
18 Thomas Kaluza-Hughes / Kevin Griffiths
19 Viktor Wozniak / Sandon Gupta
20 Caden du Plessis / Max Birtley
21 Ben Martin / Caleb Seumanutafa
22 James Biss / Will Barrett
23 William Barrett / Jonty Nicholas

UVic (Oct 3rd/current)

1 Jack Marshall
2 Jeffery Young
3 Kale Jones / Brendan Kim
4 Carter Ebrahim
5 Alex Gordon
6 Muiredach Casey
7 Aiden de Wit / Robert Reid
8 Robert Reid / Ronin Smith
9 Reece Thompson
10 Jack Driscoll / Cooper Coats
11 Keegan Neary / Alex Gamage
12 Lockhart MacGregor / Josh McIndoe
13 Grady Watt / Lockhart MacGregor
14 Thoran Koyote / Keegan Neary
15 Michael Oughtred
16 Grady Curran
17 Brendan Christian / Kale Jones
18 Brendan Kim / Brendan Christian
19 Seb Isherwood / Aiden de Wit
20 Jaxson Jones
21 Lachlan Crooks / Greg Leitch
22 Luke Hamilton / Grady Watt
23 Noah Dickens / Spencer Cotie

Ravens 47 v Vancouver Rowing Club 19 @ Jericho Rugby Park @ 2:30
Ref: Cole Northcott AR: Phil Webster, Griffin Skinner

As expected a comfortable win by the Ravens, +28 differential. Ravens go top of the standings 4-1 and 21 points, Rowers stay at the bottom of the standings, 0-5 and 3 points. Next week Ravens host Bayside and Rowers visit Meraloma.

PREGAME

#2 hosting #11. The Ravens at home will want to erase the memory of last week’s defeat, their first defeat of the season. It’s unfortunate for the Rowers that they’re next up. They sit bottom of the table looking for their first win.

Ravens have a fully loaded roster, Lucas Rumball at openside flanker. It looks like a number of national team players have the green light to play this weekend before taking off on tour. Josiah Morra back on the wing, Lockie Kratz at centre, missing is Takoda McMullin at fullback, Andrew Coe takes his place.

Rowers only had 18 listed in last week’s roster, same this week.

This should be a lot to a little, Ravens looking to get back on track, fully loaded, at home. Prediction: Ravens by +18.

Ravens (Oct 17th/current)

1 Josh Tweed
2 Louis Kassapian
3 Kaleb Whitelaw / Owen Kokan
4 Don Carson
5 Frank Carson
6 Matthew Chan / Brian Ndirangu
7 Brian Ndirangu / Lucas Rumball
8 Joe Locke
9 Max Kahler / Paddy Kirwan
10 Jamin Hodgkins
11 Niko Andrianos / Josiah Morra
12 Lockie Kratz / Ethan Berry
13 Hamish Janes / Lockie Kratz
14 Cole Keffer / Niko Andrianos
15 Takoda McMullin / Andrew Coe
16 Brendan van der Merwe / Joseph Sargeant
17 Grant Newell-Madu / Dennis Gianacopoulos
18 Dennis Gianacopoulos / Kaleb Whitelaw
19 Hillyard Carson / Matthew Chan
20 Drew Denford
21 Paddy Kirwan / Max Kahler
22 Ethan Berry / Cole Keffer
23 Lewis Ahrens

Rowers (Oct 3rd/current)

1 Greg Crowe / Josh Waller
2 Chris Cairns
3 Conor Kelly
4 Relmu Wilson-Valdez
5 Ryder Germain / Sven Ewans
6 Ben Madge / Ben Caulfield
7 Ben Caulfield / Thomas Parry
8 Thomas Parry / James Whelan
9 Luis Salvado
10 Jack Usher
11 Martel Wolfenden / Nick Jr Tuilua
12 Hayden Jones
13 Dax Millington
14 Sam Stoddard / Caleb Saunders
15 Jordan Wilson Ross
16 Jake Schwartz / Gregory Crowe
17 Ian Prendiville / Jake Schwartz
18 Sawyer Herron / Ben Madge
19 tbd
20 tbd
21 tbd
22 tbd
23 tbd

Meraloma 26 v JBAA 44 @ Connaught Park @ 2:30
Ref: Doug Thorpe AR: Thomas Cooper, Rupert Whiting

The Bays remain the only undefeated team in the league with a +18 road win. Bays are 4-0 at 20 points, the Lomas 3-3 at 17 points. Next week the Lomas host Rowers while the Bays have a bye.

PREGAME

#3 hosting #4. The Bays postponed their match last weekend against UVic until Dec 4th, their last match was October 3rd. They have a 3-0 record, the only undefeated team in the competition. The Lomas have won their last 3 matches after losing their first two.

The Lomas have Conor O’Brien starting at #8, he returned last week but was in the reserves. Corne Ludick moves to flanker. Ethan Chambers comes off the bench to start at scrum half with Polynesia Crichton missing from the roster. Aaron Leahy gets the start at outside centre.

The Bays have another strong lineup, Botchar, Matchem, Creighton, Flesch all suiting up. Their backline of Lloyd, Flesch, Bowen, Thiel & Thiel is national level.

This should be an interesting one, the Lomas with two back to back 50 point games, the Bays undefeated so far this season. I’ll have to go with the undefeated record. Prediction: Bays by +5.

Meraloma (Oct 17th/current)

1. Andy McMeel
2. Mark Rickard
3. Kabongo Mukendi
4. Craig Trimble
5. Ronan Coffey
6. Eoin Buckley / Corne Ludick
7. Andy Readman
8. Corne Ludick / Conor O’Brien
9. Polynesia Crichton / Ethan Chambers
10. Anzac Tipene
11. Carlos Thompson
12. Nathan Booker / Eoin Dorgan
13. Eoin Dorgan / Aaron Leahy
14. Mitchell Stokes
15. Jacob Walmsley
16. Hayden Kuresa
17. Bob Letiu
18. Luca Aukuso
19. Dylan Hickey
20. Conor O’Brien / Eoin Buckley
21. Ethan Chambers / Ryain Ahearn
22. Evan Gerbrecht / Ben Pope
23. tbd / Evan Gerbrecht

JBAA (Oct 3rd/current)

1 Scott Warner
2 Austin Creighton
3 Wyatt Pilz / Tyler Matchem
4 Callum Botchar / Harrison Archdekin
5 Jaiden John / Callum Botchar
6 Will Rennard
7 Brendyn Beck / Alex Jordan
8 Alex Jordan / Michael Nieuwenhuysen
9 Thomas Burton
10 Craig Mitchell-Hermann
11 Mostyn Findlay / Kainoa Lloyd
12 Kainoa Lloyd / Josh Thiel
13 Noah Flesch
14 D’Shawn Bowen
15 James Thiel
16 Neil Trainor
17 Omar El Gayed
18 Tyler Matchem / Wyatt Pilz
19 Harrison Archdekin / Jaiden John
20 Michael Nieuwenhuysen / Brendyn Beck
21 Lane Bowker
22 Isaac Gonevou / Ty Driscoll
23 Ty Driscoll / Ryan Boothroyd

Women’s Premier

A few questions around the women’s Premier, the Seattle games are apparently exhibition, they play each team once, will the BCRU system count the results and award points? The Ravens have two defaults in a row, how will this weekend’s match be recorded, will rosters be published?

Castaway Wanderers 19 v Westshore 54 @ Windsor Park @ 12:45

Westshore remain top of the standings at 4-0 and 20 points. CW go to 1-3 and 5 points. Next week Westshore host Meraloma and CW have a bye.

Westshore (Oct 17th/current)

1 Sioa Bloomfield / Madeleine Lemay
2 Emerald Maze
3 Zoe Williams
4 Aila Norlin
5 Sammy Poetker
6 Maya Addai
7 Brooke Horsfall / Claudia Vallance
8 Sammy Spence
9 Abigail Hall / Taylor Funk
10 Vanessa Chiapetta
11 Sophia Duffield / Sydney Tasic
12 Taylor Funk / Abigail Hall
13 Rebecca Zaparolli / Amber Vallance
14 Jillian Fulton / Eden Kilgour
15 Cypress Des Ormeaux Schmidt / Rebecca Zaparolli
16 Claudia Vallance / Brittany Sims
17 Mele Baleinamoto / Soleil Brooks
18 Hailey Sampson / Sioa Bloomfield
19 Shalya Stigant
20 Tiara Buchanan / Clara Inbrigtson
21  Amber Vallance / Brooke Horsfall
22  tbd / Jamie-Lee Walker
23  tbd / Jillian Fulton

CW (Oct 17th/current)

1 Josie Pusch / Quinn Murphy
2 Jamie Rikley-Krindle
3 Bronwyn Zodichi
4 Quinn Murphy / Jamie Knaggs
5 Marina Skakun / Kassidy Cej
6 Kassidy Cej / Temitope Ogunjimi
7 Ruby Lastiwka
8 Olivia Corbett
9 Emily Samek / Gwynnie Fry
10 Jenna de Greeff
11 Emmie Pearce / Louise Erikson
12 Gianna Felicella / Bella Anderton-Teasdale
13 Lily McCluskey
14 Isabella Thwaites / Juliette Cernovitch
15 Kara Katan / Emily Samek
16 Adrienne Shepherd
17 Kelsey McKinnon
18 Alexa Nash / Marina Skakun
19 Jordis Furdal / Alexa Nash
20 Gwynnie Fry / Jordis Furdal
21 Emma Mowry / Lucy Beauchemin
22 Juliette Cernovitch / Gianna Felicella
23 tbd / Campbell Bucci

Ravens 48 v Vancouver Thunderbird 12 @ Jericho Rugby Park @ 12:45

Kudos to the Ravens on their first win, and publishing their roster, even though it was only 20 players, it’s a start and better than the 11 players on October 3rd. The Thunderbirds have gone quiet and didn’t publish a roster this weekend, so no idea what sort of team they fielded. It doesn’t really matter as the UBC first team players will move over at the end of the university season, and they’ll go from last place to contending for a 6th straight title by spring. The Ravens go 1-3 and 6 points, the Thunderbirds are 1-2 and 5 points. Next week the Thunderbirds visit Burnaby, the Ravens host Seattle. The Burnaby v Seattle match was marked as cancelled on PlayHQ this week.

Ravens (Oct 3rd/current)

1. Lauren Deal / Kelsey Clark
2. Talia Hennessey / Jordan McLeod
3. Gabrielle Knox / Lauren Deal
4. Taphy Lai / Lyric Atchison
5. Madi Makara / Gabrielle Knox
6. Jordan McLeod / Caoimhe McManus
7. Caoimhe McManus / Tessa Strom
8. Emma O’Halloran / Jade Farhat
9. Olivia Sarabura / Nicola Smith
10. Alayna Scramstad
11. Cindy Sha / Emma Due
12. tbd / Olivia Sarabura
13. tbd / Delaney Woods
14. tbd / Cindy Sha
15. tbd / Madi Makara
16. tbd / Emma O’Halloran
17. tbd / Kayla McDougall
18. tbd / Alex Sy
19. tbd / Robyn Alexander
20. tbd / Talia Hennessey
21. tbd
22. tbd
23. tbd

Thunderbirds (Oct 3rd/current)

1 Makenna Kamiya
2 Adinah Sheppard
3 Tegan Jost
4 Arlee Henry
5 Meridith MacDougall
6 Annika Theben
7 Bronwyn Parker
8 Sophie Cisak
9 Ella Hudon
10 Katie Sumners
11 Emily Wang
12 Sofia Shortis
13 Chloe Bong
14 Emily Barr
15 Lanae Davenport
16 Minai Haupt
17 Mirai Haupt
18 Adelaide Williams
19 Layla Walker
20 Summer Rozell
21 Adrianna Huber
22 McKinley Ho
23 tbd

Burnaby Lake v Seattle @ Burnaby Lake Rugby Club @ 12:45

The match was marked as cancelled on the PlayHQ site. Seattle social media didn’t make any mention of the match, Burnaby put out a roster but haven’t updated since then.

Burnaby (Oct 3rd/current)

1. Emily Duffy / Ada Okonkwo
2. Chelsea Rodgers
3. Tess Woldring
4. Simran Gillar
5. Charmaine Sheffield / Nicole Stephenson
6. Grace Tuivatukalo / Charmaine Sheffield
7. Carmen Suchodolski / Gabrielle Hindley
8. Ada Okonkwo / Carmen Suchodolski
9. Natasha Lalonde / Faith Nishi
10. Renee Swetman
11. Ava van Santen / Scarlette Milburn
12. Jess Pico / Danni Fearns
13. Laisana Likuceva / Jess Piotrowski
14. Hannah Hibbs / Jess Pico
15. Jaidyn Mawhinney / Nicole Murchison
16. Lauren Tagg / T Thompson
17. B Love-Morgan / Emily Duffy
18.  A Chen / B Love-Morgan
19.  Emily Van Gulik
20. T Thompson / A Chen
21.  N Murchison / Grace Tuivatukalo
22.  Faith Nishi / N Hewko
23.  J Piotrowski / M Chan

Posted in BC Premier, Front Page.

18 Comments

    • Madi Gold must have a portal to an alternate dimension? She is on every Comox gamesheet but also somehow at Jericho playing for the Ravens? I love Science!!!

    • It is a sham when you put in a team that is not really an organic club team but women who were developed by other clubs and then pulled into a culture that winning is number #1 either by $$$ or misleading affiliation. I don’t blame the ladies, they are young and life will teach them later in life the value of loyalty, honor, respect and grace of winning or losing. Just my opinion but my questions to the women who are on the team, what made you decide to play on this team? Did you play for this club when you were juniors?

      The Ravens should have entered a Divison1 women team and built from that organically as they are constantly reminding the public they have a great juniors program, unless this is false…….and……

      • God help us all…look at me defending the Ravens (check the thermometer in hell!!) but after a cursory glance at the team list from Saturday, off hand, I could see at least 9 recently graduated UBC Varsity women’s players. Many UBC women’s players who are NOT from this neck of the woods, but stay local after graduation, remain in an around the Kits/Point Grey/Endowment Lands neighborhoods.

        In years past, those girls (either by recommendation from coaches, or by proximity) wound up at Meralomas or Burnaby. How would having the current ex-UBC players joining those clubs be any different? Neither of those teams have stand alone U-18 women’s programs, and haven’t been a club of note at the junior girls level since before COVID. So…it is safe to say that a total of zero mainland Premier women’s teams are doing it (choose one from your weirdly specific adverb or adjective list) HONESTLY/LOYALLY/RESPECTFULLY/GRACEFULLY through their junior programs…

        The clubs in the lower mainland with continuously robust junior girls programs are Langley and Abbotsford, full stop. Bayside, Capilano and United are usually in the hunt at that level, but it is cyclical, and there are peaks and valleys. None of those five teams have Premier Women’s sides (at the moment), and while a handful of current Ravens athletes are products of these clubs, if their goal is to play at a higher level (as most male athletes are continuously told to do by the pocket-picking ne’er-do-wells who make up the League of Extraordinary Poachers™) then what do you suggest they do in the interim?

        I agree that the defaults and the switcheroo shenanigans over the past two seasons, prove that the Ravens Senior Women are not an actual BC Premier Women’s team, and the league itself might have been better served not having them be a part of it, thereby creating more actual competitive games for the (ever-shrinking amount) of other premier women’s teams in BC. So on that point, you will get no argument to the contrary from old Zug Zuig, Canada’s most knowledgeable Swiss-Romansh rugby fanatic.

        But, strike while the iron is hot, and all that. If the Ravens didn’t try and start that team now, those players all bugger off elsewhere, and the potential clubs they’d go to aren’t anymore “entitled” to those players than the Ravens are.

        Food for thought, and the eating’s good!

        • ZZ, good comments and I will add my two bits to your comments:

          “In years past, those girls (either by recommendation from coaches, or by proximity) wound up at Meralomas or Burnaby. How would having the current ex-UBC players joining those clubs be any different? ”

          In years past $$$/stipends provided to woment to play did not exist.. $$$ is creeping into the women. Observe what $$$ has done to the men’s league, it has ruined it.

          ” None of those five teams have Premier Women’s sides (at the moment), and while a handful of current Ravens athletes are products of these clubs ”

          The above Comments are correct, that is because the Women Prem league is max. out. There just is not enough talent (yet) to start a new Woment prem team, but that does not mean it cannot happen in the future, just bring it on gradually

          The information below was brought to my attn

          Under BC Rugby’s current 2026/27 Senior Rules of Competition, a club entering the Men’s Premier League must also enter and compete with:

          Men’s Premier
          Men’s Division 1
          Boys U16 or U18
          An Age Grade Girls OR Senior Women program

          So the rule does not specifically say that the club must field a Senior Women’s team. A qualifying Age Grade Girls program can satisfy the women/girls component.

          Where it becomes important for the playoffs

          Section 6.5 on playoff eligibility provides that a Premier team can become ineligible for the playoffs if it fails to maintain its Conditions of Entry. More specifically, it says that if the required accompanying team defaults more than two matches, or a required additional team fails to play at least three-quarters of the regular season, the Premier team will not be eligible for the playoffs.

          The Men’s Premier conditions also state that the club must satisfy its Conditions of Entry throughout the season, and must fulfil fixtures across the teams it enters

          Section 6.5 says that if the required accompanying team defaults more than two matches, or a required additional team fails to play at least three-quarters of the regular season, the Premier team will not be eligible for playoffs.

          Interesting

          • I can see we both share our love of a light, evening reading of the Rules of Competition, my brother!

            Ravens also has a U-16 Girls team, correct? Well at least it says “Ravens” on the tin, but is an amalgamation of (last I checked) four different rugby clubs. Furthermore, I am not really sure where, how or when the rules will be applied, but I am certain public reaction to the rulings will be measured, calm and nuanced!!!

            As for the Women’s Premier division:

            I disagree with you that there isn’t space for more Premier Women’s teams. I think the potential for a healthy, viable league is as high as it has been since COVID. But the league has had some trouble keeping momentum going or staying competitive, for a number of reasons, most of them beyond the players and the league’s control. Which I am sure it is frustrating for everyone involved.

            UBC at full strength, and in full flight, is about as professional a rugby setup as you can get in this country. The “T-Birds” over the past few seasons have pasted just about every other club team so thoroughly that it often impacts the rest of the opponent’s season. They have also, in the past, seemed to be in possession of an infinite conveyor belt of young talent, that was allowing them to basketball score-line teams in the WD1 and WD2 as well. There is nothing wrong with being good at something! I suspect it has driven the non-student players and sides to try and up their game to match the T-Birds. Which is great! Iron sharpens iron!

            So, I am certainly not advocating for BCRU to Millenial-Avocado-Toast the women’s premier league and say UBC IS TOO GOOD, THEY MUST GO! But the unintended consequences of such a muscular dynasty, brings its own set of problems. Most notably, that to avoid the UBC/Westshore juggernauts, a few borderline W-Prem teams have stayed down in WD1 a season or two longer than they should have, while putting their own morale-diminishing, injury-causing scorelines on some of the mid and lower tier teams in the division. These less powerful WD1 teams then either have a hard time convincing new and returning players to sign up and get their heads caved in weekend after weekend OR they slip into the WD2 and bash around the weekend warriors in the developmental league, until BC Rugby has no choice but to pop them back up again. The WD2 teams, as a consequence, cannot sustain healthy numbers against various WD1 Wolves in WD2 Sheep’s clothing, and either fold, or become masochists.

            …and the sad saga of misery and ruin continues.

            It sucks, but there is infinitely more travel amongst the women’s leagues than the men’s, especially with strong teams in some of the farther-flung regions of our merry province, and the thought of being a player having to take a lengthy bus, ferry or van trip every single weekend, to rinse or be rinsed by their opponents, seems anxiety provoking, unsustainable, and probably, if we are being honest, a bit of a waste of everyone’s time.

            Maybe more regionalized play would help, or maybe a seperate Fall and Spring season, or maybe creating a regional Eastern and Western valley team to compete, or spreading the carded athletes amongst the various clubs. I don’t have any answers, but I have seen with my own eyes that there is a large player pool of high level rugby athletes in this province, who, for various reasons, are outside of the Premier league looking in.

            But there is one thing I think we can all agree on: the last person BC Rugby would call for help on this issue is a mentally declining, Swiss-Romansh recluse, who spends his days chit-chatting on the BC Rugby News Dot Com website. Sorry gang, Zug Zuig is off the case!

  1. Just a layman’s observation but how does a premier women team, that has default twice in a row and then is able to raises a team that goes on to beat the defending BC Women Premier champion team (Five times 2022-2026) and quite emphatically? Kavi Toor, UBC Athletics and Recreation should be looking into this matter from an oversight of perceived coaching, conduct, player eligibility and ethic. Kavi should look into this as other clubs area also sensing something is “rotten in the state of Denmark”

    The optics of the defending BC Women Premier team getting a shellacking by a team that previous, defaulted twice because of a lack of players and then this outcome? Just my opinion, but to me something is amiss.

    7
    1
    • It ain’t Watergate, brother! I wouldn’t think too hard about it…their top 25+ girls were all at the Canada West tournament. The girls remaining were likely Van Thunderbirds Div 1 players who were pulled up, as well as some of their first year “thirds” players. A quick scan of the Play HQ roster would show as much…download the app, it is great for information gathering purposes, unless a player has clicked the dreaded “PRIVATE PLAYER PROFILE” box, in which case… anything goes!!!

      • The loss was not the issue “Watergate”, the issue was, after two consecutive default (games to be played and traveling to the Island) where did the players come from?

        • The Ravens rosters from Sep 26 and Oct 24 have considerable overlap. Or maybe they bought a 3-D printer and created some Cyborg rugby players sent back in time to change the comments section of a local rugby enthusiasts hobby website?

          Why do I feel like you’re the same person, but you keep forgetting to click the checkbox “Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.”

          It is so convenient, my brother! This technology does not yet exist in the Romansh enclaves of Switzerland, but our best and brightest minds in the Canton of Grisons are working round the clock! Eviva!

  2. Herre are the lsit of players:

    Here are the two 19-player lists side by side.

    # Round 1 Round 2
    1 Angelina Alexander Adinah Sheppard
    2 Robyn Alexander Tegan Jost (VC)
    3 Lauren Deal Arlee Henry
    4 Danika Ewen Meredith MacDougall
    5 Jade Farhat Annika Theben
    6 Madi Gold Layla Walker
    7 Talia Hennessy Sophia Toledo-Cisak
    8 Gabrielle Knox Summer Rozell
    9 Taphy Lai Chloe Bong (C)
    10 Meghan Lindsay Yixue (Emily) Wang
    11 Jordan McLeod Adrianna Huber
    12 Caoimhe McManus Ella Hudon
    13 Olivia Sarabura Emily Barr
    14 Alayna Scramstad Bao Tran Hoang
    15 Cindy Sha Mirai Haupt
    16 Nicola Smith Bronwyn Parker
    17 Tessa Strom McKinley Ho
    18 Alexandra Sy Katie Sumners
    19 Quaila Trang Sol Park
    Quick comparison

    Round 1: 19 players
    Round 2: 19 players

    Players common to both lists: 0
    Different players: 38

    Therefore, based on the lists you’ve supplied, Round 2 is a completely different 19-player group from Round 1.

    You have 38 different Girls, how can you default twice? Can anyone explain this? Just my observation

    • Layman, I think you’ve made an error in your analysis…you have put Ravens Women’s roster from Sep 26th in one column, and the Thunderbirds Women’s roster from Oct 24th side-by-side. There would be no players common to both lists because they are… two separate club teams.

      Ravens Roster (Oct 24):

      Robyn Alexander (Both)
      Lyric Atchison
      Kelsey Clark
      Lauren Deal (Both)
      Emma Due
      Jade Farhat (Both)
      Talia Hennessy (Both)
      Gabrielle Knox (Both)
      Madison Makara
      Kayla McDougall
      Jordan McLeod (Both)
      Caoimhe McManus (Both)
      Emma O’Halloran
      Olivia Sarabura (Both)
      Alayna Scramstad (Both)
      Cindy Sha (Both)
      Nicola Smith (Both)
      Tessa Strom (Both)

      So 12/19 repeaters.

      For comparison’s sake:

      T-Birds Roster (Sep 26):

      Adinah Sheppard
      Angel Boswell
      Annika Theben (Both)
      Ayva Kennedy
      Bronwyn Parker (Both)
      Caitlin Pearce
      Chenuki de Zoysa
      Chloe Bong (Both)
      Ella Hudon (Both)
      Ella Kirk
      Emily Barr (Both)
      Lanae Davenport
      Meredith MacDougall (Both)
      Piper Logan
      Ruby Kaltiainen
      Sara Tehrani
      Saylor Pickrell
      Summer Rozell (Both)
      Tegan Jost (Both)
      Teniola Epemolu
      Yixue (Emily) Wang (Both)

      9/21 repeaters.

      I am not sure where the disconnect is happening for everyone here. T-Bird’s Roster from Sep 26th featured several varsity (and in some cases national level players like Piper Logan) who were absent from the Oct 24th game because they were either injured or with the UBC Women’s team at the Canada West tournament. Ravens, by comparison, dressed a similar roster in both games, but added two former Canada U20 players (Atchison and Makara) to their lineup. If this was Draft Kings, I would’ve been mashing the money line on UBCOB Ravens for this game.

      It ain’t rocket science…it is barely Grade 8 chemistry.

  3. Just a follow up question, are all the 38 players registered and have they all paid their dues? If they are, great. Also that again begs the question if all 38 players are registered and paid up member of the club, you know what you signed up for, unless you were told otherswise or your dues are being paid by the club, what is it?

    • Sham, honestly lad, are you the dues inspector? Must be an exhausting job. If a player is listed on Play HQ, they are eligible to participate in a game, everything else is semantics and pedantics.

      From what I can tell, Ravens appear to have a fairly fluid player pool of between 19 and 25 women. Some of them are not from Canada. Some of them are from other clubs in the Lower Mainland who do not currently have a Premier side. Some of them are ex-UBC Varsity players. One of them appears to be Takoda or Talon McMullin’s girlfriend.

      Have they had enough players to sustain a Premier Women’s club week in and week out since the beginning of last season? No.

      Have they had enough players to sustain a Premier Women’s club week in and week out since the beginning of this season? Not really.

      Might they in the future? Perhaps.

      Are they recruiting and trying to fill out their roster for the remainder of the season to fulfill their match obligations? Looks like it.

      Are they paying for players to pay? Are they directly paying players to play? I have no idea!

      There is an old Swiss-Romansh proverb that goes like this: Tgi ha mess ora ils chauns?

      The world has so many unknowns! Spooky!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *